Particle Picking

1. Selecting a box size

All of the projection-matching and reconstruction involves multiple Fourier transforms per particle. It is therefore a good idea to find a box size that transforms fast (Note that simply expanding the image size to a power-of-two size does not necessarily mean the fastest transformation). The program bfft has an option to test the speed of Fourier transformation for different image sizes:

bfft -test 2,250,260

Timing the execution of fast Fourier transforms:
FFTW planner option:            0
Number of dimensions:           2
Size range:                     250 - 260

Size	Ptime	Etime	Prime factors
250	0.00723	0.08392	2	5	5	5
251	0.03657	0.08565	251
252	0.01181	0.11592	2	2	3	3	7
253	0.07655	0.00492	11	23
254	0.06900	0.23176	2	127
255	0.15219	0.00303	3	5	17
256	0.00438	0.04742	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	2
257	0.10456	0.08203	257
258	0.22105	0.09444	2	3	43
259	0.09175	0.00598	7	37
260	0.00661	0.08395	2	2	5	13

Ordered times:
Size	Etime
255	0.00303
253	0.00492
259	0.00598
256	0.04742
257	0.08203
250	0.08392
260	0.08395
251	0.08565
258	0.09444
252	0.11592
254	0.23176

The FFTW3 library used for Fourier transformation has an optimization capability that is typically included when it plans for a particular size transform. This can be switched on for the tests:

bfft -test 2,250,260

Timing the execution of fast Fourier transforms:
FFTW planner option:            1
Number of dimensions:           2
Size range:                     250 - 260

Size	Ptime	Etime	Prime factors
250	0.50410	0.00204	2	5	5	5
251	0.86033	0.00336	251
252	0.57269	0.00184	2	2	3	3	7
253	1.45545	0.00182	11	23
254	1.59815	0.00177	2	127
255	2.72546	0.00144	3	5	17
256	0.29502	0.00122	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	2
257	2.36167	0.00198	257
258	3.26567	0.00167	2	3	43
259	1.30502	0.00184	7	37
260	0.59385	0.00128	2	2	5	13

Ordered times:
Size	Etime
256	0.00122
260	0.00128
255	0.00144
258	0.00167
254	0.00177
253	0.00182
252	0.00184
259	0.00184
257	0.00198
250	0.00204
251	0.00336

Now the planning time (Ptime) is much longer, but the execution time (Etime) is much shorter. The differences in execution time between the different sizes are also smaller, but still significant to do this test to pick a box size.


2. Picking particles in bshow

The fastest way to pick particles is to open a parameter (STAR) file for all the micrographs in bshow. To activate the creation of boxes for picking, click on the boxing tool in the tool panel (menu item "Window/Tools"). This will bring up a dialog box where the particle box size and bad area radius can be set. A typical particle can be selected and the box size set appropriately (the bad area radius is usually about a quarter or third of the box size). All the particles can be picked (left button) and deleted (shift-left button), and bad areas selected (control-left button or right button). The particle picking dialog box has buttons to move forward or backward through the series of micrographs referenced in the parameter file.

In the case of more than one micrograph per field-of-view, the particles in only one should be picked. This is typically the further-from-focus micrograph (usually the second one in each focal pair).


3. Finding particle locations in other micrographs in a field-of-view

Once all the particles have been picked in one micrograph in a field-of-view, the locations in the other micrographs can be found by aligning the micrographs to first one. This is most commonly done where the particles were picked in the further-from-focus micrograph and their locations need to be transferred to the closer-to-focus micrograph. All of the micrographs can be aligned using one command line:

bmgalign -v 7 -align mic -ref 2 -resol 2000,30 -correlate 1024,1024,1 -out klh_aln.star klh_*.star > klh_aln.log &

To check the alignment, look for the key word "Best fit" in the log file:

grep Best klh_aln.log

The last number on each line gives the RMSD in pixels of the alignment, where values below 5 pixels represent good fits, below 10 is still acceptable, but any larger values indicate incorrect alignment. Visual inspection of the particle coordinates in the closer-to-focus micrographs should be used to assess the success of alignment.

This alignment is not always successful, and the parameters that can be adjusted to improve it are the resolution limits (option -resolution) and the size of the tiles used for correlation (option -correlate, typically adjust it to larger tile sizes).


4. Particle extraction

Once all the particle coordinates are specified in the parameter files, the particle images can be extracted (change to the part directory first):

bpick -v 7 -extract 100 -back -norm -partpath ../part -partext pif -out klh_pick.star ../mg/klh_aln.star

The paths in the parameter file are very important for the programs to find the images. Several of the programs processing parameter files have -*path options that should be used to set the paths for micrographs, power spectrum images and particle images. If the images are written in undesirable directories, this should corrected with the various -*path options.


5. CTF correction

If desired, the extracted particle images can then be corrected for the CTF (change to the ctf directory first):

bctf -v 3 -data float -back -action flip -resol 2000,10 -partpath ../ctf -out klh_ctf.star ../part/klh_pick.star

All the modified particle image files should be written to the ctf directory.